Jury Awards Apple $539 Million in Samsung Patent Case

He stated on the stand that as of spring 2018, Qualcomm nonetheless was trying to win a contract supplying chips for iPhones however that it hadn’t “had any new enterprise” from Apple since its earlier contracts expired. Because of the trial’s evidence date limitations, he wasn’t allowed to debate the present state of Qualcomm’s business with Apple. Matthias Sauer, an Apple government and a witness known as by Qualcomm, testified that Intel’s modems didn’t meet the technical requirements required for the corporate’s iPhones in 2014.

Though Intel additionally couldn’t meet Apple’s chip necessities for the iPad, it will’ve used them anyway, he stated, had Qualcomm not supplied incentives to stick with its chips. The FTC criticism specifically associated to how Qualcomm handled Apple.

Android gadgets give you a variety of authentication options. Samsung’s recent Galaxy phones, for instance, let you choose fingerprint, retina or facial recognition. Williams’ comments appeared to contradict testimony from Qualcomm CEO Steve Mollenkopf from earlier within the FTC trial.

The US authorities mentioned that Qualcomm forced Apple to pay licensing charges for its technology in trade for using its chips in iPhones. It also argued that Qualcomm used its position to demand unreasonably excessive licensing charges and hurt competition by refusing to license its expertise to chip rivals.

Qualcomm said in a grievance that Apple makes use of this “second source of chipsets” to strain it in business negotiations. In one case, a choose saidApple’siPhoneshave infringed aQualcommpatent and ought to be banned from sale.

But a full fee review in a second, separate case saidApple did not infringe Qualcomm patentsand dismissed that suit. It also filed swimsuit against Apple within the Southern District of California. The iPhone 6, 7 and 8 all use Apple’s Touch ID fingerprint recognition to allow you to log in with one contact, but they don’t offer facial or retina recognition. The iPhone X provides facial recognition but no fingerprint or retina possibility.